ThinkThankThunk

Dealing with the fear of being a boring teacher.

5

How I Teach Calculus: A Comedy (Concavity)

This post is a part a larger series documenting the changes I am making to my calculus course. My goals are to implement standards-based grading and to introduce genuine applications of the concepts being taught. I’m not suffering any delusions that any of this is all that ground-breaking, I just want to log the comedy that ensues:

The students and I have spent some considerable time working with optimization. This technique really shows them the value of differential calculus, and I don’t mean wal*mart “value.” By doing optimization out of “order” I’ve also introduced the concepts of critical points and increasing/decreasing behavior in context. We spent a few days working — fairly traditionally I might add — on these two concepts, but always within the context of optimization.

The next concept that naturally follows is concavity, or the behavior of the second derivative. Here’s what I thought to myself: “Concavity really shows a kind of acceleration. The slopes may be positive or negative, but they might be getting more or less positive or negative.” I’m also very concerned with obfuscation. I hate the idea of real-world examples for the sake of real-world examples. As a commenter pointed out, there’s even a little push back in the research world against real-world examples.1 As much as one, vaguely-written study synopsis can show, I think we can all agree that students need to be attacked from multiple angles. I do mean attacked, by the way.

So I Googled a bit, I sat and pondered. Eventually I came up with economics, specifically marginal cost — The amount of resources necessary to produce the next amount of product. I also decided to fold in a little discussion on advertising. I came up with a little Javascript program about the Super Bowl. Not my best work, but the kids totally got it.

Sewer Tour

I gave them a toy situation to play with, which modeled the behavior of a website based on how many times you ran your ad during the super bowl. The kids then plotted the data given by the program in Excel. This is what I would consider very structured. I have pre-programmed this site, I have decided what they will do. Despite looking student-centered, this activity really was teacher-centered, at best it’s “hands on.” It also worked famously. See “attacked” above. Here are some student generated graphs:

ad chart

Hits vs. $ (millions)

Discussion ensues. Why are the curves shaped the way they are? Hypotheses fly. We start talking about some basic marketing psychology. Funny’s only funny a few times. Serious just gets your name out.

“How much money would you recommend spending?” I ask. At this point I haven’t said the words “marginal cost,” “infelction point,” or event “derivative.” The kids come up with all sorts of ideas. They start hinting at the idea that you’d want to get the most new hits per dollar; after this point you still gain hits, but not as many per extra millions of dollars. They identify the inflection points. I’m not kidding; I was floored. They derived the concept of marginal cost on their own. I start to wonder if they even need me.

I ask, “What’s happening to the slope that this point?” A student explodes, “It’s the fastest it ever gets!!” Holy crap, yes Timmy. We call this an inflection point. The lesson begins. I pull up the source code and show them how the program worked. (You can too, just go to View->Source, the functions are on lines 26 and 31) They like seeing code. I haven’t taught them much yet, but we will later.

So the lesson on the second derivative test begins. Pretty standard, but I feel that their brains have been primed with the concept first. I’ve never had something this contrived go so well.


1. Education Research. Where do I begin? I feel like we’re all just sophists when it comes to ed research. We read what we like if it supports our strategies. We marginalize the research we don’t like saying it’s just done by quacks in Europe. I’m also pretty young, and probably offending all of my higher ed readers. Here’s what I do: I try stuff on my kids, and when they can generalize it to unique situations, I keep that strategy.

Shawn Cornally • March 30, 2010


Previous Post

Next Post

Comments

  1. AnonProf April 4, 2010 - 7:57 pm

    When you have to really search to find compelling real-world examples, that might be the world trying to tell you something: maybe you’re teaching the wrong material (material that isn’t as important as you thought). For instance, why are we requiring everyone to learn calculus? A large fraction of our students will never need to learn it. Sure, for folks majoring in economics, engineering, hard sciences — you gotta know it. But not everyone.

    I say this as a former mathematician and someone who really enjoyed learning calculus. But I realize that just because I loved calculus, doesn’t mean that it’s important for everyone to learn it.

    • Shawn April 5, 2010 - 12:54 am

      AnonProf:

      I’m not totally sure what you’re getting at, but we most definitely do not require everyone to take calculus. I generally have about 5% of the student body take calc per year; those who are interested in the STEM track in college, so I suppose you’re dead on. Your tone is coming across a bit condescending, I hope that’s unintentional.

      =shawn

  2. Andrew March 30, 2010 - 11:54 pm

    As an Algebra 2 teacher, I’m loving your writing. Your detailed and refreshing thought process always provokes me to consider something differently in my teaching. Thank you.

    Any chance for an RSS feed? I’d love to put you in the Google Reader rotation to stay totally current.

    • Shawn March 30, 2010 - 11:57 pm

      Andrew:

      Yup, I think I have a feed set up correctly. You can use “www.shawncornally.com” in your add subscription input on Google Reader, or you can use this link, which is available in the footer of every page: “http://101studiostreet.com/wordpress/?feed=rss2″ Sorry it’s a bit hard to find, I guess didn’t think people would be looking to follow me. Thanks!

      =shawn

  3. Tweets that mention Think Thank Thunk » How I Teach Calculus: A Comedy (Concavity) -- Topsy.com

Comments are closed.